Top 5 Tips for Choosing an ERP

ERP systems run the most important parts of your business. 

They handle your money, track your inventory, manage customer orders, and keep production moving. 

When your ERP works well, everything flows like the proverbial well-oiled machine. When the system fails, your whole company feels more like the Tin Man.

Of course, if only it were so easy to find the right system. 

The key is pretty simple. So simple, folks often miss it:  You can’t find a solution without knowing what the problem is.

According to Panorama Consulting, 54% of ERP projects go over budget because companies skip the hard work of defining what they need before buying. The right system should fit your needs, connect with your current tools, and grow as your business does. 

Let’s take a deeper look at how to find the right system that will deliver the results you deserve. 

Because choosing an ERP system may be more important than it’s ever been.

Why ERP selection goes wrong for 54 percent of companies.

ERP systems have changed so much in the past decade. Heck, AI wasn’t even a thing back then. 

Modern platforms do far more than basic back-office tasks. Today’s systems connect with customer apps, work on mobile devices, provide instant reports, and link with partner networks.

This growth creates opportunity and challenges. You can automate more, see more data, and run more efficiently. But you also have a lot more factors to weigh when choosing an ERP system. The wrong choice creates problems, limits flexibility, and forces costly workarounds.

And an ERP is a serious long term commitment. Most companies use their ERP for 10 years or more. If AI is only a few years old, can you imagine what another 10 years will look like? 

The platform becomes the foundation of your business operations. Replacing the system or making major changes later disrupts everything and costs a fortune. So choosing right the first time matters. A lot.

Companies that pick carefully set themselves up for growth. If you rush or focus on the wrong things, you can get stuck with a system that doesn’t meet your needs.

why ERP selection goes wrong more than half the time

Five tips for getting the results you need.

Smart selection comes down to asking the right questions and checking answers carefully. These five tips offer a framework for making the right decisions that match your business goals and operational needs.

Tip 1: Start with your business needs, not feature lists.

Oh, those incredible lists of features.

It can be so tempting to pick ERPs based on what the system offers in terms of features. 

But that’s like going shopping for custom downhill skis when you don’t even have a winter coat at home. Features only matter if they solve real problems and support actual workflows. 

Instead of starting with the features that look exciting, start your selection process by looking closely at your business needs, pain points, and strategic goals.

Get input from every department early in the process. 

Finance needs specific reporting and compliance tools. Operations need inventory management, production planning/scheduling, and execution management. Sales wants customer relationship tools and order processing. Each department has unique needs that an ERP must handle.

Figure out the must-have features your business can’t run without to help you narrow down vendors and prevent paying for features you’ll never use.

Consider how your business might change. Are you planning to expand internationally? Will you need new capabilities in three to five years? Your ERP should support today’s needs while leaving room to grow.

Tip 2: Check if the system fits your industry and processes.

Functional fit means the ERP can handle your specific workflows without needing tons of custom coding. Some vendors focus on certain industries and already have features for common needs in those markets. Others offer general platforms that need more setup work.

To figure out what you need, you’ll need to define how your teams work.

Document how orders move through your system. Track how inventory flows through your facilities. Mark financial close processes. Then check how each ERP handles those workflows.

You don’t need a system that matches every single process exactly. 

Let me explain.

Your ERP has to fit the way your industry works. 

Every manufacturer has rules you can’t break: quality checks, production steps, compliance needs, batch records, traceability, and reporting. If the system can’t handle these out of the box, you’ll spend more money, delay go-live, and fight problems every time the software updates.

Some workflows can improve during an ERP project. 

This is a chance to fix bad habits and use best practices built into the system. But some processes are core to how your plants run and cannot change. You need to know the difference early, or the ERP will feel like something your team has to fight instead of something that helps them. It’s a coat that looks good on the digital storefront, but tugs in just the wrong places once you try it on at home. 

When a system needs heavy customization just to handle basic work, it becomes harder to support and creates upgrade delays. Every extra change turns into one more thing that can break later.

Focus on systems that support your most important processes right away. Some customization is normal, but you should know upfront what you need, how the system handles it, and what the long-term effort looks like.

Tip 3: Make sure the system connects with your other tools.

No ERP works alone. 

You have other systems handling specific jobs, from HR platforms to transportation management to customer portals. So, your ERP needs to share data with these systems smoothly and reliably.

Which means …you need a clear way to pull everything together. 

Be sure your ERP offers it.

Connection capabilities vary a lot across ERP platforms. Some vendors provide pre-made connectors to common business apps. Others require custom coding for each connection, which increases complexity and cost.

Modern ERP platforms can easily plug into other software. These connections make it simple to add new tools as your business changes. Older systems make sharing data harder and force your team to manually update or toggle between programs.

If the same information exists in different systems, you’ll need to decide which system holds the official version and how updates move between them. Without clear rules, you get mismatched data. People stop trusting the numbers.

For example, if you send purchase orders and invoices electronically to customers and suppliers, you’ll want an ERP that can handle that type of data exchange.

Think about future connection needs, too, not just today’s requirements. Your technology will change over time. The ERP should handle new connections without major custom work.

Tip 4: Calculate the full cost, not just the sticker price.

ERP costs go way beyond initial software licenses. 

Every project budget should account for the full lifecycle, not just software licenses. Key costs include:

  1. Set up services. Initial configuration, environment setup, and implementation planning.
  2. Data moves. Migration, cleansing, and validation of information from legacy systems.
  3. Training. Preparing users and administrators for adoption and long-term success.
  4. Infrastructure. Hosting, hardware, security, and network resources for ongoing performance.
  5. Customization. Configuration or development to align system workflows with business needs.
  6. Ongoing support. Monitoring, troubleshooting, and maintenance to sustain system health.
  7. Future upgrades. Version updates, regression testing, and change management to maintain compliance, performance, and new feature adoption.

 

Different systems have different prices. Cloud solutions typically cost less upfront, but ongoing subscription fees cover software, infrastructure, and support. On-site systems need bigger initial investments but may cost less after setup. 

And, costs can vary a lot. 

Setup costs are often higher than planned. Moving data takes longer. Teams need more training than planned, and custom work can be harder than expected. ERP systems also need regular updates, performance checks, and fixes.

These steps add up fast. That’s why you need to include partner time or internal staff time when you estimate the total cost of ownership.

Yes, there’s more.

You must consider the cost of picking the wrong system. 

Failed launches, abandoned projects, and systems that never deliver value represent huge waste. That risk should influence how much time and money you invest in the selection process and working with experienced partners.

Be realistic.

In expectations and in budgets. 

Take the time to project savings from cutting manual work, faster closes, better inventory turns, and improved customer service. These figures should come from real baseline measurements and estimations based on deep experience. No, they will never be perfect, but if you can budget carefully and be sure to include extra funds for overruns, you’ll be in a much better situation than 90% of companies out there. 

Tip 5: Check out vendor capabilities and partnership potential.

That’s important.

Vendor relationships start after you buy the product. 

You’ll need them for updates, help with technical problems, training, and advice for many years to come. So, think carefully about what the vendor can do, how stable their company is, and how committed they are to their product.

Start with the basics: Is the company healthy? Are they improving the product? Are they releasing real updates, not just small patches? 

A vendor that keeps investing in the system is a vendor that will stick with you long term.

Then look at how well they know your industry: Do they know the problems you deal with? Can they build features that match real plant work? Do they have partners who understand your processes?

Support is another big factor. Some vendors let you talk to experts who can actually fix things. Others route every call through a help desk that knows very little. Ask what support is included, what costs extra, and how long it takes to get help when something stops working.

Check the partner network. A strong network gives you choices. You can find partners with the right industry experience. You can get technical specialists when you need them. And you have backup options if your first partner does not work out.

Look at the community around the product. User groups, training programs, good documentation, and learning resources tell you the vendor cares about helping customers. These groups make it easier to learn the system and solve problems proactively..

Talk to companies that already use the system. What was the setup like? How does support work in the real world? What went wrong, and what went right? Would they choose the same vendor again?

A good consulting partner can help you compare vendors, see things you might miss, and build a plan that fits your business instead of just repeating vendor slogans.

How Corning Data supports smart ERP decisions.

Corning Data provides ERP consulting services that help companies handle selection decisions and maximize setup success. With over 40 years of experience across IFS, JD Edwards, NetSuite, and other enterprise platforms, Corning Data consultants bring deep technical know-how and broad industry knowledge to every project.

The team has supported hundreds of launches across manufacturing, distribution, life science, food & beverage, chemicals, aerospace, and other sectors with complex needs. Each consultation starts with thorough requirements gathering and business process analysis. That foundation shapes vendor checks, fit assessment, and setup planning.

Vendor-neutral guidance from selection through launch.

Corning Data maintains vendor-neutral relationships that allow recommendations based purely on customer needs rather than partner deals. The consulting approach is all about long-term success, not just project completion.

Corning Data supports customers through vendor selection, contract talks, setup planning, system setup, data moves, training, and post-launch tuning. Senior consultants stay involved throughout to ensure continuity and accountability.

You gain access to experts who understand both technical capabilities and business operations. That combination proves essential when checking how specific ERP features translate into real improvements and business value.

Corning Data also offers ongoing managed services for companies that want to ensure their ERP keeps delivering value long after launch. These services include watching for problems, performance tuning, release management, and strategic guidance for continuous improvement.

Contact Corning Data today for an ERP selection consultation. The team will check your requirements, review options based on your specific needs, and provide tailored recommendations that set your company up for long-term success.

Do You Need Help with Selecting an ERP?

Corning Data is your trusted partner for strategic ERP consulting and implementation guidance.